Agreed. It is my understanding that because the Counterfeit/Copy market has grown so much that the Clone/Knock-Off market has shrunk a little. Either way they are fakes. I thought I would share this article I wrote a while back on another blog when challanged that Clones/Knock-Offs were o.k. and a good way for people to get started in golf:
Lynn Mayhew
Hey Gang,
I hate the Clone business and any operator who promotes and sells them. I have reprinted some thoughts. Before the bombardment comes just to clarify:
Clone/Knock-Off Golf Clubs: Have cosmetic resemblance to true Manufacturer Clubs, but internally they are not the same. Construction, Material, or Quality. They may have similar names Turner T7, Gallery, and so on. A Clone or Knock off is not hard to see. Go to eBay, or Diamond Tour. Turner T7 that resembles a TaylorMade r7.
Counterfeit/Copy Golf Clubs: Are direct copies of OEM equipment. Lasers are used to copy the exterior of high selling clubs; again, there is no internal accuracy, nor the same construction, material or quality. Counterfeits or a Copy, are much harder to tell and that is why the Golf manufacturers are in fact going after these factories.
Component Golf Clubs: Such as, Infiniti, SMT, Nakashima, and KZG, are original designs and are legitimate and ARE NOT part of any reference.
Knock-Offs/Clone Golf clubs operate in a gray area. Determination of trademark infringement is tough to prove and costly. Although new legislation is going to clarify this further.
Major Brands, members of the U.S. Golf Manufacturers Anti-Counterfeiting Working Group, have their hands and funds fully committed at the moment going after Counterfeit Clubs.
What's the harm in buying a Knock-Off/Clone? Counterfeit Clubs and Knock-Offs are manufactured in the same factories in China. So while, technically you may not be buying and thereby promoting counterfeit clubs, you are in fact enabling those same facilities to continue by buying Clones/Knock-Offs.
Let's connect the dots. Nearly all Clubheads come from China and Thailand. The rest (save for some Ping), come from Japan. The factories that produce for legitimate OEMs are not permitted to make clones. Those factories are inspected regularly by the OEMs. They are legitimate. (That’s not to say that the occasional employee sneaks off with a proto clubhead).
Clones come from the same Chinese factories that produce Counterfeit clubs. Thereby, purchasing Clones ultimately supports those factories who build Counterfeit clubs.
Quality wise, any golfer regardless of handicap is better served buying quality used equipment or buying a new but discontinued model.
If a component seller such as Diamond Tour wants to be fully legitimate, they need to invest fully in true component companies such as SMT, and abandon the practice of selling Clone clubs. Counterfeit Clubs and Clone Clubs, the operators who sell and produce, contribute to higher prices of the legitimate brands.
There are just too many cases backing up the problems. It has become rampant and that is why Acushnet (Titleist/Cobras), Adams, Callaway, Cleveland, Ping, and TaylorMade are part of and formed the U.S. Golf Manufacturers Anti-Counterfeiting Working Group.
However, China cannot enforce without participation of the Patented/trademark holder. Which they are doing, but it is costly. There have been recent factories busted in China. They are concentrating on Counterfeits and Copys, but again, Clones and Knock Offs are part of the same problem. There just simply is not the time or money right now to go after them.
One doesn't have to be an Attorney to read or be educated on the law. To say that a consumer has no responsibility is, well sad. It is the consumers who have the most power to affect change. Consumers changed the cars that Detroit made by speaking out and buying economical foreign autos.
One more time; Clones are referred to as Knock-Offs. Counterfeit Clubs are also referred to as Copies. Two different items under the law, but part and parcel of the same problem.
Neither are quality because while laser technology can scan the outside, it cannot scan the inside. There are many reasons besides marketing costs why they are cheaper. Material used is cheaper. No Research and Design Costs. No Reps. No Service. No U.S. or Japan assembly.
It doesn't cost that much more to purchase legitimate past year models. It does however cost money to get started in golf. Starting should also include lessons. A PGA Professional will give a lesson to anyone, but ask them if a Clone/Knock-Off club is a good choice and see what type of answer you will get. For those who feel Clones perform just as well as OEM - I won't argue that point, you have convinced yourself.
This site is full of PGA Professionals, Company Reps, and the suggestion to use Clone/Knock Off clubs is disrespectful. Golf is a game of honor. You invest your time and should invest equally in your equipment. Clones are a short cut. Make yourself aware. Goggle "Counterfeit Golf Clubs" and take a look at how rampant it is. Read further and you will find that the same factories involved are also producing Clone Clubs.
It may be understandable that we as consumers can be fooled by Counterfeits/Copys (Illegal), but there is no way anyone of us could not identify a Clone/Knock-Off (Legal). It is your decision and right (for the time being) to buy a Clone/Knock-Off. It just isn't admirable.
For those who want to play Knock-Offs, yes it is your "right". Just ask yourself, have you ever had someone take credit for your hard work? Has anyone ever stolen an idea or proposal you have written? Has anyone ever stolen a customer of yours? Do you not find all of those cases wrong, frustrating, and near impossible to prove? Knock-Offs operate under the same principle. Someone else designed it, so they're going to laser copy it, skip the R&D, use cheaper material, spend nothing on advertising the new design, and take money from a certain consumer segment. The uninformed, the newbie, the consumer who is jealous of the success of OEMs and their need to earn profits.
There is a difference in this world with having "the right" to do something, and doing something with honor. It would be more honorable for a person to show up with RAMs purchased at Target than to use Knock-Offs/Clones. The later hurts the Golf Manufacturers and the integrity of their designs, thereby hurts all involved, Reps, Retailers, and yes ultimately the game of golf.
Ultimately my point in all of this is that of all Sports activities, Golf is a gentleman’s game, it is honor, and it is self-policing. Those involved in this great game should have a certain level of ethics. Not driven only by what is legal, but what is righteous.